Author Guidlines
Constitution Journal invites authors to submit original scholarly manuscripts addressing constitutional law, state administrative law, local government regulations, comparative constitutional law, legislative studies, Constitutional Court decisions, and other related legal issues. Authors are required to prepare their manuscripts in accordance with these guidelines and the official Constitution Journal Article Template.
Manuscripts must demonstrate originality, academic rigor, a clear legal or scholarly contribution, and appropriate engagement with relevant literature, legislation, court decisions, and previous research.
1. General Requirements
Before submitting a manuscript, authors should ensure that their submission meets the following requirements:
- The manuscript is original and has not been published previously.
- The manuscript is not being considered for publication by another journal.
- The manuscript falls within the focus and scope of Constitution Journal.
- The manuscript follows the prescribed article structure and formatting requirements.
- All sources cited in the manuscript are properly acknowledged through footnotes and a bibliography.
- All authors have made appropriate scholarly contributions and have approved the submitted manuscript.
- The manuscript has been checked for spelling, grammar, clarity, and consistency.
- The author has completed the required submission information in the journal's online submission system.
2. Manuscript Length and Formatting
Manuscripts must be prepared in paragraph format and follow the specifications provided in the official Constitution Journal template.
| Element | Requirements |
|---|---|
| Manuscript length | 4,000–8,000 words, including footnotes. |
| Main text font | Book Antiqua, 12 pt. |
| Line spacing | 1.15 spacing. |
| Title | A maximum of 15 words. |
| Abstract | Approximately 150 words in English and Indonesian. |
| Keywords | 3–5 words or phrases in each language. |
| References | At least 15 references. |
| Citation style | Chicago Manual of Style, 17th Edition, Full Note. |
Authors should use the official journal template to maintain consistency in the layout, headings, footnotes, tables, and bibliography. The template takes precedence for detailed formatting matters not explicitly described on this page.
3. Title and Author Information
The manuscript title must be concise, informative, and relevant to the main issue discussed in the article. The title must not exceed 15 words. An English title and an Indonesian title should be provided in accordance with the journal template.
The names of all authors must be written clearly beneath the title. Each author's institutional affiliation should identify the faculty or department, university or institution, and country. Authors must provide valid email addresses. The corresponding author must be identified and must be available to communicate with the editorial office throughout the editorial process.
Author names, affiliations, and contribution information entered in the online submission system must be consistent with the manuscript. Changes to authorship after submission must be explained and are subject to editorial approval.
4. Abstract and Keywords
Each manuscript must include an abstract in both English and Indonesian. Each abstract should contain approximately 150 words, use Book Antiqua 11 pt, and be formatted with justified alignment and single spacing, following the official template.
For research articles, the abstract must explicitly describe the research objectives, methods, and principal findings. For review articles, the abstract should present the purpose, scope, principal arguments, and conclusions of the review; a research-method section is not required solely for a review article.
Provide 3–5 keywords or keyword phrases in English and 3–5 in Indonesian. Keywords should represent the most important concepts, legal issues, theories, or subjects discussed in the manuscript. Use Book Antiqua 9 pt in italics, as specified in the template.
5. Article Structure
Authors should organize their manuscripts according to the type of article submitted. Research articles should generally follow the structure below. Review articles may adapt the structure to their purpose while retaining a clear, logical, and academically rigorous presentation.
5.1. Introduction
The introduction must explain the background and significance of the topic, provide relevant preliminary information, and establish the legal or scholarly problem addressed by the article. It should clearly state the research question or issue, the objective of the article, and a concise review of relevant previous studies.
Authors must identify the state of the art and explain how the manuscript differs from, develops, or contributes to existing publications. The introduction should establish the originality and significance of the proposed contribution rather than merely listing previous studies or reproducing statutory provisions.
5.2. Research Method
For research articles, the method section must explain how the research questions are addressed. In legal research, authors should identify the type of research, research approach, sources of legal materials or data, techniques for collecting legal materials or data, and methods of legal-material or data analysis, as applicable.
The method must be sufficiently clear to allow readers to understand the basis of the analysis and assess the appropriateness of the research process. Authors should explain the relevance of the selected approach to the legal problem being examined.
5.3. Results and Discussion
This section must present the principal findings or arguments and discuss them analytically, critically, and systematically. The discussion should follow the research questions or legal issues identified in the introduction. Relevant theories and previous studies should be integrated into the analysis to explain the significance of the findings.
Where relevant, authors should analyze statutory provisions, regulations, judicial decisions, legal doctrines, and other authoritative materials. Quotations or descriptions of legal provisions must be accompanied by the author's own analysis and argument. The section should demonstrate how the findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the issue.
Tables may be used where they improve the clarity of the analysis. Tables should be presented horizontally where appropriate, accompanied by a clear title and source. Every table must be discussed in the text; it should not appear without an explanation of its relevance to the argument.
5.4. Conclusion
The conclusion must directly answer the research questions or legal issues stated in the introduction. It should summarize the principal conclusions concisely and clearly, based on the analysis presented in the article. The conclusion must not introduce new evidence, new arguments, or discussions that have not been addressed in the main text.
5.5. References
The bibliography must contain all sources cited in the manuscript and must correspond to the footnotes. Authors should include only references that are actually cited in the article. The minimum number of references is 15, in accordance with the journal template.
6. Citation and Footnote Style
Constitution Journal uses footnotes as its referencing method. Authors are encouraged to use Zotero or Mendeley to manage citations and prepare footnotes and bibliographies according to the Chicago Manual of Style, 17th Edition, Full Note system.
Footnotes must provide sufficient bibliographic information to identify the cited source. Authors must apply the selected citation style consistently throughout the manuscript, including for books, journal articles, websites, conference proceedings, and legislation or regulations.
6.1. Books
A book citation should include the author's name, book title, publication information, and page number where applicable. The bibliography entry should follow the Chicago Manual of Style 17th Edition format.
Example of a footnote:
Jimly Asshiddiqie, Konstitusi & Konstitusionalisme Indonesia (Jakarta: Konstitusi Press, 2005), 25.
6.2. Journal Articles
A journal article citation should include the author's name, article title, journal title, volume, issue, year, and page number or other relevant locator. A DOI should be included when available.
Example of a footnote:
Dyah Ochtorina Susanti and A’an Efendi, “Pancasila Dalam Teori Jenjang Norma Hukum Hans Kelsen,” Legislasi Indonesia 18, no. 4 (2021): 515.
6.3. Websites and Online Sources
Citations to online sources should include the author or responsible institution, page or document title, publication information where available, and the relevant URL. Authors should prioritize authoritative and reliable sources.
6.4. Conference Proceedings
Citations to conference proceedings should identify the author, paper title, proceedings or book title, relevant publication details, and page number where applicable.
6.5. Legislation and Regulations
References to legislation and regulations must identify the instrument accurately, including its number, year, and official title. Where applicable, authors should provide the relevant State Gazette, Supplement to the State Gazette, or official source information. Judicial decisions should be identified with sufficient information to allow readers to locate the decision.
7. Reference Quality and Recency
Authors should prioritize recent and relevant scholarly publications, particularly journal articles, theses, dissertations, and national or international conference proceedings. The journal template recommends that approximately 80% of the references consist of primary scholarly sources, while the remaining 20% may consist of books or other reference sources.
References published within the previous ten years are recommended. Older books may be cited when they remain authoritative, foundational, or have not been republished in a more recent edition. The relevance and scholarly authority of each source should guide its inclusion.
Authors must verify the accuracy of all bibliographic information, including author names, publication years, article titles, journal titles, volume and issue numbers, page ranges, DOI links, and URLs.
8. Tables and Other Supporting Materials
Tables should be included only when they contribute meaningfully to the presentation or analysis. Each table must have a clear title and source, where applicable, and must be discussed in the body of the manuscript. Authors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce copyrighted material where such permission is required.
Any figures, diagrams, or other supporting materials must be legible, relevant to the argument, and properly attributed. The presentation of supporting materials must remain consistent with the article template.
9. Originality and Research Integrity
Submitted manuscripts must be original and must not contain plagiarism, fabricated or falsified information, manipulated research findings, or unattributed use of other authors' work. All direct quotations, paraphrases, legal sources, and ideas derived from other publications must be properly acknowledged.
Authors must comply with applicable ethical standards for research and publication. Any relevant research permissions, ethical approvals, or disclosures should be provided when applicable to the manuscript.
The use of generative artificial intelligence or AI-assisted tools must comply with the journal's Generative AI Use Policy. Authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, legal analysis, citations, and integrity of the submitted manuscript. AI tools must not be listed as authors.
10. Submission Procedure
Manuscripts should be submitted through the online submission system available on the official Constitution Journal website. Authors should register or log in to the system and follow the submission instructions provided on the journal platform.
Before completing a submission, authors should ensure that:
- The manuscript follows the official article template.
- The title, abstract, and keywords are provided in English and Indonesian as required.
- Author names, affiliations, and email addresses are complete and accurate in the submission system.
- The manuscript includes the required sections appropriate to its article type.
- Footnotes and bibliography follow the prescribed citation style.
- The manuscript is original and is not under consideration by another publication.
- Any required declarations or supporting documents have been completed.
11. Editorial Assessment and Peer Review
All submissions are subject to an initial editorial assessment to determine their relevance to the journal's scope, compliance with the author guidelines, completeness, and suitability for peer review. Manuscripts that do not meet the basic requirements may be returned to authors for revision before further consideration.
Manuscripts that pass the initial assessment may proceed to peer review in accordance with the journal's Peer Review Process. Authors may be required to revise their manuscripts in response to editorial and reviewer comments. Submission does not guarantee acceptance or publication.
12. Revisions and Proofreading
Authors invited to revise their manuscripts should address the editorial and reviewer comments carefully and submit the revised manuscript within the deadline communicated by the editorial office. Where appropriate, authors should provide a point-by-point response explaining how each comment has been addressed or why a suggested change has not been adopted.
Authors are responsible for checking the accuracy of the final manuscript, including author information, footnotes, bibliography, quotations, and other content, before publication.
13. Publication and Copyright
Constitution Journal is an open-access journal. According to the article template, published articles are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike (CC BY-SA) license. Authors should review the journal's applicable copyright and licensing information before submission.
Authors are responsible for ensuring that the submitted work does not infringe third-party copyright or other rights. Any material reproduced from another source must be appropriately cited and used in accordance with applicable permissions and licensing terms.
14. Final Checklist
Authors are encouraged to use the following checklist before submitting their manuscripts.
- The manuscript is within the journal's scope.
- The title does not exceed 15 words.
- The manuscript is 4,000–8,000 words, including footnotes.
- The manuscript follows Book Antiqua 12 pt and 1.15 spacing.
- Abstracts in English and Indonesian are included and approximately 150 words each.
- There are 3–5 keywords in each required language.
- The article structure is complete and appropriate to the article type.
- There are at least 15 references.
- Footnotes and bibliography follow Chicago Manual of Style 17th Edition, Full Note.
- All sources are accurately cited and listed in the bibliography.
- The manuscript complies with the journal's publication ethics and AI use policies.
- All author information in the manuscript and submission system is accurate.
- The manuscript is not under consideration by another journal.
By submitting a manuscript to Constitution Journal, authors acknowledge their responsibility to comply with these guidelines and the journal's applicable editorial, peer-review, publication ethics, and copyright policies.

